• Beware! 9 regulations that put students in a soup
  • by B Mahesh Sarma
  • print
  • |
  • |
  • Comment(s): 4
  • FROM the number of students that an institution can admit to the number of rooms that it must have, education regulators specify every aspect of the education process.

    Take the regulatory process of All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE), for instance. It has over 67 different parameters incorporating standards that an institution must meet in order to be approved. But barring the insistence on the number of contact hours, AICTE has hardly any measure to ensure a good learning experience for the student. No discussion on transparency in the admission process, none on quality of teaching, no way for the student to objectively assess his or her experience and seek remedy for being treated unfairly or getting cheated.

    The student has always felt cheated. Nearly 67 percent of the queries that Careers360 receives are about bad experiences of the students, which, in turn, is the result of bad regulatory regimes. A lack of application of mind in designing regulations, indifference to the impact of haphazard rulings on students, pious but useless sentiments about student welfare, and a colonial mindset of controls, all has resulted in a regulatory quagmire that is difficult to escape from.
     
    The pity is that most of these problems can easily be solved, if only the State looks at education through the eyes of the student. We identify nine instances where the regulatory mess has inflicted unwarranted pain on students (click on each problem to view):
     

    - Q1: Should Deemed University status be withdrawn?

    - Q2: Study centres in various States. Are they legal?

    - Q3: Can I do a B.Tech degree through correspondence?

    - Q4: PGDM and a foreign degree? Are they legal?

    - Q5: My college offers a Joint degree. Is it valid? 

    - Q6: Why should institutes be prevented from establishing campuses?

    - Q7: Should only select academic degrees be valid for becoming a professional? 

    - Q8: What do the new PGDM regulations mean for thousands of students? 

    - Q9: Should we not have a national standard? Will teaching improve?
     

     
    Dr AnandaKrishnan
    Chairman, BOG, IIT- Kanpur

    "The education system needs a paradigm shift.A national ombudsman must be set up to redress student grievances"
    Dr. M C Gupta
    Former Dean, KMC

    "Lack of consultation is the bane of India’s regulatory regime. The way to do this is to invite opinion of the stakeholders."

    Abhay Kumar
    Principal, TCE

    "The system just does not consult the stakeholders. This results in even good policy measures backfiring and students suffer"



    P J Lavakare

    Former Executive Director, USEFI

    "Even as regulations are stipulated, the officers of the agencies “certify” the unqualified institutions, because of corruption"


    Do you have a query on this issue? Careers360 will answer your queries through the month of September. Post your queries today!


  • Published on: September 14, 2011
  • 4 Comments
  • Yamary | Oct 16, 2011

  • The paragon of udnertsnading these issues is right here!
  • Yamary | Oct 16, 2011

  • The paragon of udnertsnading these issues is right here!
  • Yamary | Oct 16, 2011

  • The paragon of udnertsnading these issues is right here!
  • Mridula Sathe | Sep 14, 2011

  • Recently i had attended a seminar on MBA - PGDM. In that they speaker had sddressed that in many universities especially Pune University MBA syllabus is not updated and studnet are not given practical knowledge various some colleges though there are AICTE approved have updated syllabaus + practical industrial knowlwdge. But i am confused then whether its safe to pursue MBA or PGDM. I am aware final result of task will totally depend on my hard work my output. But will a PGDM degree will be treated with same respect honour as an MBA degree?
  • Post a comment
  • Name *
  • Email address *
  • Comments *
  • Code Verification *
  • Type the number you see in the picture below
  •       
  • Topic