Hi Pranshu! 

I think PDPU is slightly better! 

 Let's talk about this in detail...

• The campus grow from nothing to the lush green mighty campus that it has become
• The sports culture, which has now become one of the pillars of the university. Its all because of the marvelous work that students are doing every year during Petro Cup. You have coaches for every sports discipline. You get a fair shot at all the open spots on the team sheet.
• The cultural and technical events have grown in numbers and quality over the years. Through Flare and now, Tesseract. The quizzing culture and the videography, photography , street plays , all these activities have grown.
• People , localities or non localities , they gel every well together in my opinion. Try befriending a Gujarati , they are really cool people and they have their own way of living a life.
• Hostels , classrooms , mess , library and gardens. They are big and properly maintained. The festivals like Navratri and other local festivals are celebrated with full zeal and enthusiasm.
• Gaming culture, be it CS , DoTA or any other , people here are good at everything.
• Teachers though not up to the standards of IIT or NIT's but they are good compared to other colleges and with other perks that come along, its a bitter sweet trade off.
• Placements , well , they are a headache in every stream , MBA including. But , tell me one college who is not IIT, NIT, DCE,IIM, IIFT or FMS and etc. where you get those big bucks. When you compare PDPU with the colleges its competing with and being so young , it has far more pros than cons.
• The oil and gas market is down so the companies have not been visiting but then that's the case with UPES and other colleges too.

The fees is bit on the high side and the administration can do a better job.

And yes they have SLS too. Where all the creative people gather and they keep on doing something or the other which keeps PDPU in the news.

So, in totality if you ask me on a scale of 10 , I would say PDPU is 7 on 10.

And remember , we human being have this tendency of not being satisfied with what we have. Well, don't use that judgement to make opinions about things and places.

Cheers!
I hope it helps.
Do let me know what you think about the answer in the comment section.