171 Views

If a, b,and c be three distinct real numbers in gp and a+b+c=xb then b can't be


Zehra Namak 19th May, 2019
Answer (1)
NAVEEN MEENA Student Expert 20th May, 2019

Dear Student, I think you want to find the value for x as a, b and c are given real numbers in gp and as per the given relation, this can be true or false depends on the value of x.

For this relation to hold x should be grater than 3 or less than - 1.

The three numbers are in geometric progression,

(b/a) =r 

=> a=b/r and

(c/b) =r 

=> c=br
with r= common ratio of the progression.
Since a,b,c are three distinct numbers, r cannot be equal to 1 and - 1

=>a+b+c=b/r + b +br = (b +br +br^2)/r = b(1+r + r^2)/r


If a+b+c=xb then,

xb = b(1+r+r^2)/r 

=>. x= (1+r+r^2)/r

If r<0 and r not equal to - 1,

x+1 = (1+r+r^2)/r  +  1 = (1+2r+r^2)/r

=>( (r+1)^2)/r  <0

and x+1<0 => x<-1


If r>0 and r not equal to 1 then, 

x-3 = (1+r+r^r)/r  - 3 =(1-2r+r^2)/r  

=>. ((r-1)^2)/r    >0

 and x-3>0   =>  x>3. 

Hope this helps :) 

Related Questions

UPES B.Tech Admissions 2026
Apply
Ranked #43 among Engineering colleges in India by NIRF | Highest Package 1.3 CR , 100% Placements
UPES Integrated LLB Admission...
Apply
Ranked #18 amongst Institutions in India by NIRF | Ranked #1 in India for Academic Reputation by QS Rankings | 16 LPA Highest CTC
Presidency University MBA Adm...
Apply
NAAC A+ Accredited | Highest CTC 10 LPA | Top Recruiters : Amazon, Accenture, KPMG, EY, Capgemini & many more
Nirma University Law Admissio...
Apply
Grade 'A+' accredited by NAAC | Ranked 33rd by NIRF 2025
UPES M.Tech Admissions 2026
Apply
Ranked #45 Among Universities in India by NIRF | 1950+ Students Placed 91% Placement, 800+ Recruiters
UPES | BBA Admissions 2026
Apply
#36 in NIRF, NAAC ‘A’ Grade | 100% Placement, up to 30% meritorious scholarships
View All Application Forms

Download the Careers360 App on your Android phone

Regular exam updates, QnA, Predictors, College Applications & E-books now on your Mobile

150M+ Students
30,000+ Colleges
500+ Exams
1500+ E-books