Hello,

It would be better to go with MAT as you have good percentile as compared to CMAT. do check the cutoff and the process of selection. if both your score is coming in cutoff range then you can use any one.

better idea is to choose a recognized college using your best score. The main concern is what is the cutoff for MAT and CMAT. look for it and apply for admission. recognized college makes your profile look good and indicates you have done a immense effort.

Hope it helps!