3796 Views

What's the difference between M.Des at NID and M.Des at IITs for the same specialization, say Product Design for a non-engineering candidate


Mark Nongkhlaw 25th Mar, 2018
Answers (2)
Mark Nongkhlaw 19th May, 2018

Yep, there are other things to consider, which are not specifically related to product design, but to M.Des in these institutions, which might be factors worth considering.

One is that the fees at NID are very high compared to those at IITB. It looks like NID being autonomous, has to generate its own revenue, and one way of doing it is to jack up the fees. Second, there is no hostel accommodation for M.Des students at Ahmedabad campus. Third, there's no concept of teaching assistantship at NID, whereas the same is available at all IITs. Fourth, the M.Des course duration at NID is 2.5 years vs. 2 years at IITs. Fifth, the IITs, being primarily tech institutes, have vast tech resources in the same campus. For example, I notice that the Mechanical Engineering department is adjacent to IDC, IITB. That's important from an industrial design perspective.

Amita Jain 17th May, 2018

Dear Mark


Both of these institutions, IIT and NID, are among the best when it comes to Design programmes. These are among the premier colleges that are known for offering good placements as well. Every year, thousands of aspirants appear for the entrance exam conducted by the respective institute. There are about 100 B .Design seats at NID, while IIT Bombay and IIT Guwahati tentatively have about 30 and 45 seats respectively.

The basic essence of BDes. program is same in all these three institutes i.e. NID and IIT Bombay, IIT Guwahati, since the nature of degree which will be offered at the end is same, i.e. Bachelors of Design. Now what are the intricate differences between BDes degree as it is offered by NID, IIT Bombay and IIT Guwahati, can be known from the way this programme is structure at these institutes:

  • NID: There are about 15 seats in BDes Product Design at NID. The program comes under Industrial Design department, so you can expect to develop competencies synthesizing industry needs, practical problems and designing. It is a four year course. Besides Product Design, NID also offer many other specializations like Animation design, etc.
  • IIT Bomaby : IIT Bombay offers a dual degree programme of MDes and BDes, comprising 5 years. However, you will enter BDes program only, and the option to go for dual degree will become available only at the end of 3rd year. IIT Bombay also offer many specializations, but at MDes level only. Some specializations include, Industrial Design (in consonance with product design), Visual Communication, Animation Design, Interaction Design & Mobility and Vehicle Design.
  • IIT Guwahati: Unlike NID, IIT Guwahati doesn't offer any specialization at UG level in BDes. The B.Des degree here comprises imparting of knowledge of design in all areas spread across four years.

As you can see Mark, all these design institutes are well-known for imparting quality education and offers BDes, there are slight differences in the structure of which they offer BDes programme.

Besides that, I would also like to tell that NIDs are known for offering good campus placements to design students. Top design companies recruit from here. After completion of B.Design from NID, the average salary you might get will be around Rs.7 lakhs per annum.

Hope it answers you.

All the best.

2 Comments
Comments (2)
17th May, 2018
Thanks, Amita but I specifically mentioned M.Des, not B.Des. As far as IIT Guwahati is concerned, there doesn't seem to be any specialization even at M.Des level. Looks like a kitchdi course to me where all the fundas of various specializations are being taught. But I could be wrong.
Reply
17th May, 2018
Mark. Apologies. I somehow overlooked that. Yeah, you could say that about IIT Guwahati. Else, for MDes, between NID and IIT Bombay, the structure and aim of the degrees remain quite the same. The course in IIT Bombay is called Industrial Design. Product design is a part of its curriculum. IIT Bombay has also begun direct consultation with Industry allowing their students to work in industry-settings and gain experience like hospitals, etc. A variety of range from basics of design, product design to instruction in world cinema, game design, animation design is also included in the course design. At NID it is product design and the specifications are similar to its BDes. Product Design course. The curriculum would focus on the products and services for consumer needs; design and development of products that improve the quality of living in home, office and public environments, including health care needs and other societal needs. Now, whether you are an engineering candidate or not, will not impact your eligibility and should definitely not impact the potential of your gaining the required expertise, irrespective of which institute you choose. 
Reply
NID vs NIFT - Which is better

This eBook helps the students to compare the NID and NIFT, admission process, courses offered in each of the institutions.

Download EBook

Know More About

Related Questions

Pearl Academy B.Des Admission...
Apply
No. 1 Design & Fashion Institute by ASSOCHAM, India Today, Outlook and The Week rankings
UPES B.Des Admissions 2024
Apply
Ranked #52 amongst Universities in India by NIRF | Ranked #9 in India by QS University Rankings 2023 | Last Date to Apply - 30th April
Amity University, B.Design Ad...
Apply
Ranked amongst top 3% universities globally (QS Rankings)
Graphic Era (Deemed to be Uni...
Apply
NAAC A+ Grade | Highest Package (2023)-49.18 LPA
Parul University B.Des. Admis...
Apply
India's youngest NAAC A++ accredited University | NIRF rank band 151-200 | 2200 Recruiters | 30 Lakhs Highest Package
WUD | Design Admissions 2024
Apply
International tie-ups | Project based learnings | Attractive Scholarships | State of the art infrastructure | Last Date to Apply: 23rd May'24
View All Application Forms

Download the Careers360 App on your Android phone

Regular exam updates, QnA, Predictors, College Applications & E-books now on your Mobile

150M+ Students
30,000+ Colleges
500+ Exams
1500+ E-books