Both SCMHRD and Goa Institute of Management are good and renowned institutes for management programs. However, if you are looking for MBA, then i'll like to tell you that GIM dosen't provide MBA but it provides PGDM course. So you should choose SCMHRD pune. SCMHRD Pune has an average placement of 15 lakhs and provides great exposure to its students. However, in terms of better ROI, I'll recommend you to go for GIM Goa.
You can use our college comparison tool for more clarity:
See both the colleges are good and they both have their own advantages and disadvantages, their own pros and cons and their own uniqueness.
SCMHRD is a better MBA college as per my own personal opinion. I would choose it because the college surroundings is extremely well and so is it's infrastructure. I've heard a lot about it's teaching faculty and facilities as well. And it has got good placement opportunities too.
Best wishes. Thank you.